Home
Up

"Faith and Evidence"

November 10, 2002 The Rev. Dr. Will Eisenhower

 

This morning for my message, I want to reinforce the idea that God sends special people our way and that there are special people in this congregation that God has sent to many of us.  God sends special people our way.  We know that because He sent Jesus as the Special Person.  And I want us to remind ourselves what it is that we place our faith in when we say that we have our faith in Jesus, that we believe in Jesus. 

 

There is a nature to the Christian faith that we must not lose sight of.  I was reminded of that recently reading through Newsweek (of all things!).  You may have seen this as well in Newsweek.  Within the last few weeks they had a very interesting article.  It says "A Clue to Jesus?"  Have you seen that article?  If you didn't, I encourage you to get ahold of a copy.  Let's see, this is a recent Newsweek and I'll tell you which one:  November 4, 2002.  The substance of the article is this:  Archaeologists have discovered a box--an ossuary.  (An ossuary is a box in ancient times used to keep the bones of a special person.)  There are no bones in this box, but inscribed on the outside of the box in Aramaic (which was the language of the holy land 2,000 years ago) the words in Aramaic  are "James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus."  And the claim being made is that this was a special box in order to keep the bones of James, the brother of Jesus--James, the one who wrote the letter of James in the New Testament.  James was a very prominent figure in the book of Acts.  If you remember the book of Acts, James (who was a son of Joseph, and therefore related to Jesus in that way), this was a special box used to preserve his bones from ancient times.

 

Now, it's disputed, and some would say, "Oh, no, no, no--that's ridiculous."  And part of the reason for the dispute is that there are those today who say Christianity is nothing but a myth.  One reason that is said is there are those who argue that all religions are nothing but myth, and so you cannot take the claims, the historical claims, of any religion at all seriously.  Well, this finding gives something of a black eye to the leading voices who would say Christianity is nothing but a myth, because there should not be archaeological evidence like this, where it is written, "James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus."  What this find . . . (and because of the archaeology of the holy land, you probably know this) all the time confirmations of what the Bible has claimed about ancient times, all the time confirmations are being found, just like this, that would say, "Hmmm.  Isn't that interesting?  You know, the book of Acts tells us that James was a very important person in the early church, a very prominent person, and now here is an indication that there really was such a figure, that that figure lived at exactly the time and in exactly the place that the Bible says that he did."

 

Well, unfortunately, Newsweek, I think, really missed an opportunity.  Because Newsweek's article becomes obsessed with the person of James and wants to answer the question, "Who was this James that is being referred to here?" when there is a much more important question, and that is the nature of Christian faith and evidence that is found that confirms the claims of that faith.  And that's what I want us to confront together this morning as we remind ourselves about that special Person, Jesus Christ, that God sent into the world to be our Savior.  So you may want to turn with me as we look at 1 John, the first of the letters of John, 1 John chapter 1, beginning with the first verse.  This is what John writes:

 

We declare to you what was from the beginning, what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes, what we have look at and touched with our hands, concerning the word of life--this life was revealed, and we have seen it and testify to it, and declare to you the eternal life that was with the Father and was revealed to us--we declare to you what we have seen and heard so that you also may have fellowship with us; and truly our fellowship is with the Father and with his Son Jesus Christ.  We are writing these things so that our joy may be complete. 

 

Now, first of all, the most important thing that we see in this passage is that John is claiming to be an eyewitness.  He's claiming to have been there, and he's saying, "I've got sense-data type information about what I want to tell you about."

 

We declare to you what was from the beginning what we have [watch this:] heard . . .

 

He's saying, "Hey!  I heard it myself.  I was there.  I heard what Jesus said."

 

. . . what we have seen with our eyes . . .

 

OK.  So, "I heard it.  I saw it.  I was there.  I observed the entire thing."

 

 . . . looked at and touched with our hands . . .

 

So, "I heard.  I saw.  I sort of looked at it in a more penetrating kind of way, a very careful examination."

 

 . . . and touched with our hands . . ..

 

"You know, we knew what it was to walk along and to hand something to Jesus.  He was a real, live person.  He was flesh and bones.  I'm not telling you about a fairy tale.  I'm not telling you about a dream.  I'm not telling you about something that the human mind has just sort of imagined.  No, I'm going to declare to you what I saw, what I heard, what I looked at and carefully examined, what I touched."  Verse 2

 

This life was revealed and we have seen it and we testify to it and we declare it to you.

 

So, on the first instance what we need to understand is this letter of John, and the New Testament, and the Bible, and the Christian faith, make claims about things that really happened in history, things that were empirically detectable.  You could see it.  You could hear it.  You could touch it.  Jesus Christ was a real human being.  He lived among other real human beings and interacted the way real human beings did.  So the claim that the Christian faith makes--the claim that John is making here in his letter--is this is not a vision somebody had at a particular time.  This is not a dream that somebody had at a particular time.

 

And, I know it's preposterous, but some people will say, "Oh, all that stuff in the New Testament--that was invented by Roman Catholic priests in the third century.  I mean, you know, there's nothing to it other than that."  Well, that's preposterous because we know who John was.  John was one of the twelve disciples of Jesus.  We know that this is his writing.  And what he's saying is, "I was there.  I saw it.  And I'm going to tell you about this historical person who actually lived among us."

 

Now because of that claim, we should not be surprised when the archaeologists dig up something that is a burial box--you know, the box with no bones.  James' box of bones, or James' empty box of bones.  You know they did a Broadway musical "Joseph's . . ."  What was it?  "Joseph's Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat."  I want them to do one now, "James' empty box of bones."  You don't think that would work?

 

This is a very, very small, but nevertheless significant in its own way, bit of evidence that the things that the New Testament writes about impacted the world.  And if we are thorough enough, we will continue to unearth little pieces of evidence that say, "You know what?  What the Bible says is true.  What the Bible says is true." 

 

But, on the other hand, let me qualify what I'm saying in this way:  It is not the case that our faith rests on new evidence being found so that you would want to say, "I'm really not sure whether Jesus lived or not.  I'm going to wait 'til they find more boxes of bones, and then after they've found some more evidence like that, then I'm going to make up my mind," because Christian faith has always depended on the trustworthiness of the testimony of the authors of Scripture.  Our faith has always depended upon the trustworthiness of the people who were there, and that is exactly what the letter of John is inviting us to do.  He's saying, "I'm going to tell you about what I saw.  I'm going to tell you about what I heard.  I'm going to tell you about what I . . . and the reason I'm going to do that is. . ."  Why?

 

We declare to you [verse 3]  We declare to you what we have seen and heard so that you also may have fellowship with us and truly our fellowship is with the Father and the Son.  We are writing these things so that our [some of the versions say "your"] so that your joy may be complete (our joy may be complete, we have a joyous fellowship together) . . .

 

. . . because of the eyewitness testimony being declared.  Every week, all around the world today, Christian preachers preach the gospel.  And the claim that the Bible makes is when these truths are declared that way, God is available.  God is receivable in the preaching of the Word, so that Jesus Christ is as available to you right now, today, in the preaching of the Word, as Jesus Christ was back then.  Now you say, "Well, how can that be?"

 

Well, number one, it's not the case that everybody who watched Jesus, who heard Jesus speak, who touched Jesus with their hands--it's not the case that everyone who had those experiences came immediately to faith in Him, is it?  Well, no.  We know that actually many people who saw Jesus, heard Jesus, even people who were aware of His miraculous power rejected Him, objected to what He was saying and rejected Him, and that He was crucified by God's chosen people, people who saw Him, who heard Him.  There's nothing to say that if you or I had been there at the time . . . 

 

You may be saying, "I'm having a hard time believing today, but if I were alive 2,000 years ago, then I would believe.  You know, if I had been there, if I had seen what John saw, I'd believe a lot more."   Well, we really shouldn't try to make that claim.  We might--I might--have been among the ones who rejected Him.  I might have been among the ones who called for His being crucified.        

 

So it took a miraculous anointing for those who saw Jesus, who heard Jesus, who touched Jesus, to see with the eyes of faith that this is the Messiah sent from God.  And that same miraculous anointing is available in this room today.  You can have a faith in Jesus, because of the preaching of the Word, that is as sturdy, is as solid, is as certain, as the faith that John has.

 

You say, "Well, John was lucky.  He got to see, and touch, and hear.  I'm not lucky.  I didn't get that."  Well, you know what?  The claim of this letter is that when he declares his first-person testimony to us, God touches that testimony and brings it to our hearts in a way so that we can believe.

 

Now, we shouldn't be surprised when we learn from Newsweek that there is confirming evidence, that archaeologists find item after item long-buried in the sand that is exactly what you would have expected based on what the Bible declares.  But our faith doesn't rest in what Newsweek says.  Our faith doesn't rest in what the archaeologists find.  Our faith rests on the Word of God, and hearing the Word preached, and allowing God to minister the truths from here [the Bible] right into here [our hearts], to build up our faith and give us a confidence that, yes, it's what the Bible says it is. 

 

This is what John says.  He says:

 

This is what I'm declaring to you.  I'm declaring this to you so that you can have life.  What we're declaring is that which was from the very beginning, the beginning of time, before the creation of the world.  It's the eternal life that appeared to us and we saw it and we're declaring it to you so that you  can share in that eternal life, and so that the fellowship that we all experience as believers can be made complete.

 

Now, this is the point in the sermon where you say, "OK.  But, Will, why are you telling me these things?"  In fact, repeat that after me:  "Will, why are you telling me these things?"

"Will, why are you telling me these things?"

OK.  Good.  Why not?  That was fun!  Let's do it again.

"Will, why are you telling me these things?"

 

Because your walk with God, your faith in Jesus Christ, ought to have accompanying it, new evidence, evidence today of answered prayer, of strength in hard times, of love where you would think, "I have no idea why I'm able to love that person," or " . . . that group of people."  You know, "God has supernaturally enabled me to have a love that I can't explain any way other than to say it's a gift from God."  Your walk with God ought to have evidence just like that.

 

The reason that I'm telling you this this morning is that your faith should not depend on that evidence any more than the Christian faith depends on evidence like this [Newsweek].  We think that archaeological finds are to be expected.  We think archaeological evidence that supports Scripture ought to be forthcoming because of the kind of faith that Christianity is.  Christianity is a faith that God made an everlasting difference in the world when He sent Jesus, and that God continues to make a difference in your life and my life today, and so we ought to be seeing signs of the difference that God makes. 

 

If you would have to admit, "Will, you know what?  I have no idea what you're talking about.  I've never had an experience like what you're talking about.  I've never had a time where I felt like God was giving me the strength to get through an hour of difficulty.  In those hours of difficulty I've always felt like I was by myself.  Will, I have no idea what you're talking about, 'answer to  prayer.'  That's what you religious-types always say, but I have no idea what you're talking about.  I've never experienced that."  If that's true for you, then please come in and see me, and let's sit down and talk, because the normal Christian life is one where there is evidence in you, evidence in your life, of God making a difference.

 

I remember when I was (long, long ago!) I was a student at Fresno State College.  (We called it "Fresno Straight College" at the time.)  At Fresno State College I was a student and I remember I was sitting in the student union eating a hamburger, and this girl who was in my English Lit class came up, as I was just sitting there having my lunch, and this girl came up and she looked at me and she said, "You're a Christian aren't you?" 

I put down my hamburger and I said, "How do you know?"

And she goes, "Oh, I can just tell."

I have . . . I mean . . . it's not like I would go into my English Lit class and talk about Jesus all of the time, I want you to understand!  I have no idea what she meant when she said, "Oh, I can just tell."  But we're talking about a difference that Jesus can make in your life.  Evidence of God alive and real in your life.  A difference significant enough so that not only can you tell, but other people can tell. 

 

That's what John is talking about.  He's talking about, "Hey!  I want to tell you about something I've seen, I've heard.  I want to tell you about a difference that God made that was see-able, hear-able, touchable."  A difference like that.  Christianity is about Jesus making a difference like that, and Jesus is available today to continue to make a difference like that.

 

Another time, back in those same days:  A few years later I went to seminary.  I was living in Berkeley at the time.  And Connie Solberg and her boyfriend came to Berkeley.  Connie was a friend of mine.  Her boyfriend, I didn't know.  Connie called me up and wanted to go on a double-date (I was not married at the time--I need to let you know this!), but her sister lived in Berkeley.  So I went over to the sister's sorority and now I'm meeting the sister for the first time--and there was Connie (my friend) and her boyfriend. 

 

And I discovered (the second I show up) that the boyfriend is a very aggressive atheist.  A very eagerly-aggressive atheist.  And the second I walk through the door, he starts saying, "You're studying to be a Presbyterian preacher?  That's nonsense!  Everybody knows there's no God, there's no Jesus, there's no . . ." and just. . .

And there I am.  I'm kind of--you know, you walk in like that and I'm trying to go, "Well . . . um . . . um . . . yes, there is . . ."

"No, there's not!"

 

And we go downstairs and we get in the car and the whole time he's driving and he's--you know the people that drive and look in the back seat at the same time?  He's telling me why no one should ever believe in God, why no one should ever believe in Jesus.  And we get to Telegraph Avenue, and we park, and we go downstairs in the Ratskellar, and we sit down.  You know, the conversation sort of stopped as we were coming down the stairs.  We sit down at the table, and then the waiter comes right up, and the boyfriend looks up at the waiter and he says, "Waiter, excuse me.  We're having a little discussion. . . " (Connie was a believer in Jesus.  I have no idea why she had this boyfriend!  And I was a believer in Jesus.)  Nothing had been said since we got out of the car.  We came down the stairs and now we're sitting in the basement restaurant on Telegraph Avenue and the boyfriend says, "Excuse me, waiter.  We're having a little discussion.  Two of us at this table are devout followers of Jesus Christ and two of us are not believers.  We want you to tell us who the believers are and who the believers aren't."

 

The waiter right away--he had the menus in his hand--and right away he goes, "OK."  He holds the menus like this [against his chest, with his arms folded across his chest] and he goes, "You're a believer (he pointed at me) and you're a believer (he pointed at Connie)."

The boyfriend--his mouth dropped open and he said, "How do you know?"

And the waiter--this is Berkeley, California in the early seventies--the waiter just nodded and he goes, "It's in the eyes."  And he went away.

 

I have no idea what to make of that, except to report to you that the kind of faith that we have is one that will supply confirmations all the time as God makes you and me more like Jesus, as God makes us different people.  But let's not let our faith rest on whether our eyes shine or not.  Let's not let our faith rest on whether God has made us enough like Jesus yet.  Because if we do, I'll tell you, there's going to be those times when you're going to be really proud ("I'm getting more like Jesus!") and the next second you're going to fall on your face and you're going to go, "I'm not getting more like Jesus."  If our faith rests on the evidence, our faith is going to rise and fall, and rise and fall.  If our faith rests on these kind of things [Newsweek], then one archaeological find is going to be up and then another one is going to be down.  Let's let our faith rest right here [in Scripture].

 

Let's pray.  Dear Heavenly Father, we thank you that there really, really was a Jesus.  He was seen by people, He was heard by people.  And, Lord, we thank you that you empowered eyewitnesses to declare to us today the saving truths, so that hearing them as they arise out of Scripture, we might have the life that you intend for us, eternal life with you, thanks to your Son.  And it's in the strong name of Jesus we pray.  Amen.

 

The Rev. Dr. Will Eisenhower

Interim Pastor

Faith Presbyterian Church

Minnetonka, Minnesota

 

[Transcribed from an audiotape of the worship service on November 10, 2002.]